Returns and Exchanges:
At Historicsells.com, your complete satisfaction and authenticity is our greatest concern. Please
evaluate your purchase prior to payment as we do not accept returns due to the elevated amount
of fraud, including photocopies of the pieces received by the purchaser and returned to us as the
- Please call within 48 hours of receipt of package if your merchandise has been damaged
in transit of shipment or is defective.
- For damaged items we may issue a ‘call tag’ to have your package picked up. The
customer should HOLD the package for the carrier service to pick up the package for
inspection. It is the customers responsibility to see that the package is available for
pickup by carrier, or to drop off the package within 7 business days of receipt to be
eligible for refund.
- The customer must save all original packaging including packing materials to reseal the
package for return. Damage claims will not be processed if the item is not in its original
- If the transit carrier determines the item was damaged during transit we will issue a
complete refund of the purchase price of the item and shipping charges back to the credit
card used to make the purchase. Damaged in transit returns will not be assessed with
For further information on damaged goods please see our policies page.
Items NOT Eligible for return or exchange:
- All custom orders, including custom framed photos and jerseys
- Game Used and Game Issued Items
- Vintage Items
- Merchandise that has been delivered more than 30 days prior to emailing